Liver Transplant Assessment in patients with Chronic Liver Disease with the Royal Free – For Doctors

Disclaimer: This article is not intended as advice for patients but is intended as information for medical professionals only.

Firstly you have to establish the indication for transplant:


All the indications are listed here in this policy document but broadly they are broken down into:

  1. Chronic liver disease
  2. Hepatocellular Carcinoma
  3. Variant Syndrome
  4. National Appeals Panel
National appeals panels arbitrate on decisions regarding transplantation which fall outside of standard criteria

The UKELD score can be used to assess suitability for transplant. As the score reaches 49 this indicates a 9% one-year mortality rate and is the minimum criterion to be listed for transplantation. A score of 60 suggests 50% one-year mortality. Remember that these statistics were developed by looking at patients on the transplant list already so may not be applicable to new presentations.

HCC’s must be small

There are also a few pilot studies, including one for downstaging HCC’s which appeared to have a more indolent course. If patients are staged as ‘low risk’ for recurrence then they do benefit from transplantation but this is still in a pilot stage. There is also one for alcohol related liver disease but the criteria are so stringent that so far nobody has been transplanted on that pilot.

Assess the risk for that individual patient

In order to do this we need to look at survival. Every year in the UK about 2/3rds of patients are listed for transplant but around a third are deemed too unwell or needing other conservative treatment options first.

Biological factors are key and they will look at co-morbidities as well as several other factors. They will generally perform an echocardiogram, pulmonary function tests, blood gases, exercise capacity tests and some additional investigations for high risk patients. Nutrition will be assessed.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Outcomes are worse in those with BMI 40.  Recent/current extrahepatic malignancy is an absolute contraindication. Tobacco smoking is a relative contraindication as it affects prognosis post-transplant.


In the UK, if people have gone back to drinking alcohol despite medical interventions within a medium-term time interval they are not transplantable. The point of stopping the alcohol is so that the liver can recover. The commonly held myth of the ‘6-month rule’ actually doesn’t exist in reality. Most of the guidelines instead talk about 2 years as an appropriate time interval, and the definition of absitinence is usually total. This advice needs to be clearly documented in the notes. Even a glass of wine at Christmas is not strictly allowed. Alcohol-free lager is also not allowed (as above)

This is because drinking even alcohol-free lager is a risk factor for relapse. Selective engagement in treatment is another risk factos for relapse; as is previous history, access to alcohol, underemployment, relationship factors, children, social support structures and personal motivation to engage in new habits.

There are also tests that can be used to detect whether or not people have been drinking alcohol. Increasingly cigarette smoking is being strongly discouraged as well because it is associated with poorer outcomes post-transplant.

One thought on “Liver Transplant Assessment in patients with Chronic Liver Disease with the Royal Free – For Doctors

  1. This article isn’t expected as guidance for patients however is planned as data for therapeutic experts as it were. The liver is the most complex organ of the body. Liver transplant just those individual who have forbearance from liquor for broadened time frame at any rate of a year.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s